Today's top picks on TalentEgg:
Find out how to get a summer job or internship and use it to hatch your career. Buy it now!

#7: Erin Bury – Don’t equate experience with ability

Erin Bury headshot large #7: Erin Bury   Dont equate experience with ability

“When I was in Carleton University’s journalism program, I didn’t really understand how difficult it would be to get a job when I got out of school, and I certainly didn’t understand the value of networking and how much it mattered to career success.”

Erin Bury, B.A. Journalism, Carleton University

When I was in Carleton University’s journalism program, I didn’t really understand how difficult it would be to get a job when I got out of school, and I certainly didn’t understand the value of networking and how much it mattered to career success.

I was attending school in Ottawa while living in Toronto during the summers, so it was difficult for me to find relevant summer positions in my field. This resulted in a string of fun summer jobs, none of which had anything to do with my goal of securing a job in public relations, journalism or communications upon graduation.

Luckily, my mom worked in public relations and she was able to set up some informational interviews for me during my fourth year reading week. This was the best thing I could have done, as it got my name out there and gave me a feel for what life at a PR agency was like.

One of the interviews I had, at Environics Communications, resulted in my first post-grad full-time position. But that wasn’t until October and I graduated in April.

Those few months in between were really difficult. I applied for jobs constantly on sites like Workopolis, but it was like sending your resumé into an abyss.

I didn’t have a good network in place, so I often relied on family contacts to get me in the door. While I appreciate the help my mom gave me, I hated that I was getting interviews based on nepotism.

Now I realize that most people land jobs based on referrals, and that you have to take help whenever it’s offered to you. While my contacts may have gotten me in the door, it was my smarts and ambition that got me the job.

I’m thankful that I got a full-time job shortly after graduation, but it certainly wouldn’t have happened like it did without some pre-graduation networking, and introductions from trusted contacts.

Where I am now

I’m now working as the Community Manager at Sprouter.com, a small technology startup focused on providing expert answers to entrepreneurship questions. I handle all of the communications, PR, marketing, social media strategy, events, and a whole whack of other stuff. It’s been an amazing experience. I advise any new graduates to get a job at a small company. You’ll get so much experience, and you really get a sense of accomplishment and contribution.

My recommendation for employers

The one lesson I’d like to share is that you can’t equate a person’s experience with their ability. I worked at a PR agency for just over a year and, although I have a journalism degree from Carleton (regarded as the best journalism school in Canada), I was mostly tasked with administrative work: compiling lists, covering the mail room and reception, and media monitoring. I know I could have contributed more to overall strategy and content creation, but it wasn’t at my level. Don’t get me wrong, I knew I was starting at the bottom and I was happy to do whatever it took to move up the ladder. But I feel the agency and corporate structure doesn’t give lower-level employees a chance to shine.

When I moved on to a smaller company I was given the chance to take on a lot more responsibility, even though my boss knew I only had a year of experience. She trusted in my abilities, and I think it worked out well for both of us.

This #StudentVoice belongs to:

Erin Bury
Graduate
Bachelor of Arts, Journalism
Carleton University

Click here to share your own story.

  • http://twitter.com/JeffWaldmanHR Jeff Waldman

    Erin nailed this one. She’s absolutely right that you absolutely cannot equate competency with the number of years experience you possess…… BUT…… for the most part companies still believe in this relationship so yes you can fight it, but you also have to play the game. How you play the game is by having a strong network that will enable you to bypass job postings where the majority of job seekers spend their time.

  • Geoff

    I disagree that experience and ability should be considered exclusive of each other. Would you want a 747 pilot with lots of ability but little or no experience who “knows he can fly on his own”, but the airline just won’t let him? How about going to a hair stylist that has cut hair only twice but feels he has much greater ability than the salon will let him practice. I can go on and on… How about if you get sued – do you want a lawyer that has tried 3 cases or several hundred in the area of law that affects you. I believe that experience and ability cannot be separated. In each of these examples, I believe the case could be made that the more experience the person has, the more able they are to do the job.

    What I believe you are probably talking about is that potential should not be equated to experience. That is to say, that a person without experience should not be held back or put into a mold because of a lack of years of experience, because they may have great potential to develop strong abilities.

    On the other hand, perhaps there is a threshold. Perhaps we are all born with certain basic abilities, but those abilities develop and grow with experience.

    Either way – I agree in principle that some superstars are often overlooked because they are pre-judged as too inexperiened. And, in no way to I believe that years of experience automatically create ability. There is likely a mix of potential, experience, ability, motivation and probably even a little bit of luck that makes a person successful.

  • Anonymous

    Thanks Jeff :)
    I agree, you have to play the game – that’s why I advocate for working at startups so heavily, because there’s no game there. You have limited people and limited resources, and everyone has to step up and do work that’s outside of their experience level and comfort zone.

    Go networking go!

  • Anonymous

    Hey Geoff,

    You’re so right – in that case I’d like some experience AND some ability! And I’m not saying that experience counts for nothing, just that entry-level positions are often so focused on menial tasks and not on giving the person a chance to exercise what they learned in school.

    Thanks for pointing out that in many cases ability and experience should be linked, and that it’s often potential that I’m talking about.

    Cheers,
    Erin

  • Geoff

    Agreed! Startups and small companies are a great place to grow and develop outside of artificallly designed role definitions. It is more ofthen than not the case that there are huge gaps in available roles for the work that needs to get done, and those gaps get filled by people willing to learn, step in, and take a chance!

  • http://www.canadablogfriends.ca/2011/03/erin-burys-random-musings-in-toronto/ Erin Bury’s Random Musings in Toronto at Canada Blog Friends

    [...] for helping students get started, and she even helps them land their first jobs in the industry. Erin amplifies the voice of students and represents them positively whenever she [...]

  • http://talentegg.ca/studentvoice/2011/03/28-jonathan-suter-attract-and-retain-high-quality-talent-with-your-company-culture/ #28: Jonathan Suter – Attract and retain high quality talent with your company culture « TalentEgg's Student Voice – a campaign to fight youth under-employment

    [...] I now had to contend with the “years of experience” barrier – excellently outlined in Erin Bury’s post – and there were no more free mini egg [...]

  • http://talentegg.ca/studentvoice/2011/05/student-voice-in-metro-erin-bury/ Student Voice in Metro: Erin Bury « TalentEgg's Student Voice – a campaign to fight youth under-employment

    [...] journalism grad turned Sprouter.com Community Manager Erin Bury’s Student Voice story (originally published here Mar. 10, 2011) was [...]